Civil suit accuses Edmonton Oilers owner of paying teenage ballerina for sex

Update: The couple who alleged Daryl Katz had an inappropriate relationship with ballet dancer Sage Humphries has since withdrawn those claims. Read the latest here.

A newly filed U.S. civil suit claims Daryl Katz, the billionaire owner of the Edmonton Oilers, paid a teenage ballet dancer $75,000 in exchange for "her sexual favours."

The unproven allegations come in response to a sexual abuse lawsuit launched by seven aspiring ballerinas in 2021 against Mitchell Taylor Button, a dance teacher, and his wife Dusty Button, once a principal member of The Boston Ballet. 

Earlier this month, Taylor Button and his wife filed a third-party counterclaim in U.S. District Court in Nevada, admitting to a consensual "throuple sexual relationship" with Sage Humphries, the lead plaintiff in the suit. The third-party claim and counterclaim says the Buttons "had a consensual sexual relationship" with Humphries "after she had reached the age of majority," but alleges she had been involved in three prior sexual relationships as an underage teen with much older men, including Katz.

The third-party claim seeks to hold those men liable for any damages, with the filing stating that if there's a price to be paid, "it should be paid by those who actually engaged in illegal acts with her." 

A lawyer representing Katz denied the allegations. 

Screen shots of alleged texts

The lawsuit makes a number of unsubstantiated allegations about Katz, Humphries, and her family.

"Humphries was literally a child prostitute to a billionaire," the claim says, "and her mother assisted her in laundering the money she was paid and in trafficking her to Katz."

Among the exhibits attached to the filing are screen shots of texts allegedly exchanged between Humphries and Katz, as well as an iPhone contact under the billionaire's name, listing a number with a 780 area code, most commonly associated with the Edmonton area. 

"If my guys send u funds will u spend it on/keep it for yourself?" Katz allegedly wrote. "And just between us? Even though u r wise beyond your years given our respective ages it would be taken the wrong way."

"Yes .. Just between us," Humphries purportedly replies.

"OK will have one of my guys email u. He will send you 50K," says the message attributed to Katz.

The court filing says Katz was 53 at the time, while the dancer was 17.

A 'distraction and a shakedown'

Robert Klieger, the lawyer representing Katz, told CBC News that his client never had a sexual relationship with Humphries. But the pair did meet on two occasions in the spring of 2016 with regards to a project that the teenager was pitching to Katz's film company, Silver Pictures. 

"One of Daryl's friends connected him with Sage because Sage was working with some producing partners on shopping a motion picture project that they had put together, basically, and it was based in the ballet world," said Klieger. 

Klieger said he was unable to verify the authenticity of the texts in the court filing, but confirmed that the Edmonton Oilers owner did arrange for $75,000 to be sent to Humphries as part of their business dealings. 

"They ultimately decided to pass on the project. But during the period of time that the project was under consideration, they asked for some help to keep with the funding of the project to keep it going. And that's the $75,000 that is at issue," said Klieger.

The project, a remake of an independent Australian film called Tackling Romeo, remains in development, according to an IMDB listing. 

Following publication of this story, Klieger revised the dollar figure, saying that Katz paid Humphries $50,000, not $75,000, for the film work. He also provided a date of birth indicating that Humphries was 18, not 17, at the time of her film discussions with the Oilers owner. Humphries's lawyer subsequently confirmed the October 1997 birthdate to CBC News, and said that the dancer's relationship with Katz was not sexual.

Klieger said Katz will vigorously defend his reputation against the "baseless and scurrilous" claims in the suit.

"It's designed to be a distraction and a shakedown," he said.

A 'meaningless sideshow'

The third-party action doesn't explain how or when the screen shots were obtained, but the time and battery levels displayed suggests they were accessed on multiple occasions. The original civil suit filed by Humphries states that she handed over her iPhone and passwords to Taylor Button so that he might assist her in building a social media following. 

To date, no responses have been filed to the third-party motion. In a statement to CBC News, the lawyer representing Humphries and the other dancers dismissed the action as a "meaningless sideshow."

"As is typical of abusers facing serious litigation, the Buttons have filed counterclaims that distract from and distort the truth and weaponize the serious allegations of abuse that have been brought against them," wrote Sigrid McCawley, managing partner at Boies Schiller LLP. 

"Their counterclaims falsely implicate others and are an unfounded attempt to portray the women they abused as liars."

Marc Randazza, the Las Vegas attorney representing Taylor Button and his wife, declined to comment on the filing.

"We are not trying this case in the press," he wrote in an email.

Randazza describes himself as a "First Amendment lawyer," and his website highlights a number of areas of expertise, including civil rights, defamation, the adult entertainment business and the "protection of erotic expression."

He has attracted media attention for some of his controversial clients, including Alex Jones, the Infowars conspiracy theorist, and Andrew Anglin, publisher of the Daily Stormer, a neo-Nazi website. He has faced disciplinary proceedings from the Florida, California  and Nevada State bar associations

Prior sex-for-money allegations

This is not the first time that Katz has been the subject of sex-for-money allegations. 

In 2017, R.J. Cipriani, a professional gambler, filed a defamation suit against G.F. Bunting+Co, a public relations crisis management firm that was then representing Katz.

The suit alleged that Katz propositioned Cipriani's wife, model and actress Greice Santo, during a Hawaii photo shoot, offering her $20,000 a day for sex. Katz allegedly wired Santo a total of $35,000 — money she later donated to charity after rejecting the arrangement.

At the time, a spokesperson for Katz denied the allegations, calling them "false, malicious and entirely without merit."

Asked about the 2017 case, Katz's lawyer, Robert Klieger, said "there was nothing to that," offering to put CBC News in touch with Cipriani. 

"There's no continuing animosity or anything between them," said Klieger. "But I can't go into details of exactly how they resolved that."

This story has been updated with information provided by lawyers after the initial publication of the story.